Wood v Carpet in a split level
We finally decided!
Wood, upstairs and downstairs and on the stairs and in the bedrooms. The only carpet left in the house will be the guest room and the tiny section in our closet that I didn’t pull up when I did our room.
I probably overthought this whole decision but in the end it came down to a few things;
- Price – I can’t say this was not very high on the list. We both got good bonuses and this is something we want to we were ok spending a good chunk of money but we didn’t need to spend just to spend
- One would think carpet is far less expensive but that isn’t really true anymore. For a good high end carpet with a nice carpet pad you are looking at $6 a sq foot plus labor. Wood was really about the same if you shop around and our installer has a great labor rate so for a very similar price we get wood.
- Perceived quality – Here is where carpet really lost – I feel like if anyone walked into a house with basically 100% wood they would either love it or say; “well, I’ll need some area rugs” with carpet there is a chance they would love what I picked, but, better chance they would not like the choice or feel like would need to redo it or wose it is a total turn off and they can’t see past it. **we are not moving or selling, this is all forward thinking*
- Contractors – the guy who quoted both carpet and wood was insane with rates, the guy with good wood rates really didn’t do carpet so while I don’t mind working with people the ability to just coordinate with one contractor is a bonus. One guy, one timeline, one bill – nice and easy
- I’ve found that half the people I tried to work with were really really bad communicators. I don’t want to chase someone. The guy we choose is a great communicator and that plus price earned him an entire house rather than just one level.
- Now this is gross, but, we evaluated the puke/pee potential in our future and decided that while we have been lucky so far wood is so much easier to clean. In Niamh’s pukefest earlier this year I was actually glad she walked up to my room to puke on my floor since it was an easy clean up. The bedrooms are small enough that what they added to the wood bill was really not bad.
- As a bonus, we can now go a little more ‘crazy’ for carpet if we want since the local store will bind a remnant into an area rug for $2 a foot (plus carpet) so we can get a cool pink or purple carpet for a low price and not stress about resale (or puke since an area rug can be removed to the yard/tub/trash)
We ended up getting the wood through Home Depot because we are going with a prefinished floor to avoid the fumes in the house and no contracter really has a better in on this style flooring. This decision also took way too much thinking to finally say that traditional sand and finish might be perceived as slightly better, it isn’t really worth the 2 weeks of basically evacuating the house and at the very least keeping the cats away. With the prefinished there are more visible lines between boards but we minimized that by going with a micro bevel (I’ve learned a lot of new vocab in the past 2 weeks). We are also avoiding the hand scraped look since that translates to ‘choppy looking’ and we want as smooth a look as possible. Prefinished also offers more options in stain and a harder finish so those are both nice things. The final reason for prefinished is that it does not need to be nailed and our family room level is on cement so we could either have 2 different woods on the different levels or go 100% prefinished.
Color – another MAJOR point to decided. Technically it is easier to choose a wood
color since it really only comes in so many colors rather then carpet that comes in nine million different colors (not that I have analysis paralysis or anything but you know, gotta have a boundary somewhere). Our existing kitchen (in the pic below with Niamh slaving away) is builder standard red oak, as is the moldings and built in woodwork in the house. At first I wanted to match it but learned over the week that matching would look like we lived in a basketball court, and, is nearly impossible since one floor would be new and the other 10 years old. After some discussion, Lars and I both like a darker wood way better anyway. We looked at tons of options and ended up with ‘Gunstock’ in birch.
Lars does not like the light/dark variation in an oak grain and I do so birch was a compromise. It will look nice I think, some contrast but not completely different color family.
The stairs will be interesting, we are going to go with gunstock tread and red oak riser to tie the two woods together. It will be a unique feature and if I totally hate it, we can always paint the raiser or something.
We are also getting something like this stair drawer in the bottom two steps but instead of a pull out the tread will hinge up for a trunk like storage. I am a sucker for nifty storage and the trunk feels safer than a drawer that might get left open to trip on. I’ll definitely have pictures when it is done but the contractor was so excited about the idea he isn’t even charging extra for labor, just the hardware (a hinge I suppose). His plan is to do a thin mdf liner inside the stair, there will be two sides since the stringer will still be in the middle and no need for pull hardware since the riser will have an overhang anyway. Now what to put in there….
It feels good to finally have all the decisions made and a timeline that is actually moving forward since wood got ordered yesterday. As a super awesome bonus, I ordered through my credit card portal and got 10x credit for every dollar spent. That right there is an airplane ticket home~ I love when I make my money work hard for me.
Lets see if I’m still super happy about this in 2 weeks but barring unforeseen issues under the carpet it should be fairly easy, especially since a professional is doing all the hard stuff. The next week will be all about clearing the rooms – fun times ahead.